Sep 27, 2017 @ 08:15
Who is killing Canada’s passenger trains? It can’t be our prime minister.
Since he was a babe in his mother’s arms, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has been exposed to the virtues of train travel. That’s thanks to his father, Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau, who had a genuine affection and respect for passenger trains. He travelled on and campaigned from them frequently, and his government created VIA Rail Canada in 1977.
When the future Prime Minister Trudeau was six months old in 1972, his parents took him to visit his grandparents in Vancouver on the aptly-named Canadian Pacific Railway flagship, The Canadian. They travelled up the rugged Ottawa Valley, around the rocky rim of Lake Superior, across the rolling prairies and over the four mountain ranges the CPR conquered in 1885 to earn its reputation as “the wedding band of Confederation.”
Our prime minister later travelled to the Maritimes with his father and their close friends, future Governor-General Romeo LeBlanc (a railroader’s son) and his son, Dominic, who is now MP for Beauséjour. They rode aboard CN’s Ocean Limited over the railway built as a mandatory requirement of Canadian confederation in 1867. And when he took his father home to his final resting place in Montreal, it was on a flag-adorned version of The Canadian, operated by the Crown rail passenger corporation his father helped create in 1977.
Trudeau has had train exposure of late, too, including appearances at GO Transit’s Toronto shops and Montreal’s Central Station to announce funding of urban rail projects. More significantly, a recent trip carried his family’s passenger train connection to the next generation.
On July 30, the prime minister took his daughter, Ella-Grace, from Revelstoke to Calgary aboard the CPR’s Canada 150 Train. She wore a CPR safety vest and got to blow the whistle on the beaver-crested locomotive. Her father noted he was about her age when he started riding passenger trains with his father and discovered they brought families and Canada together.
But what of Canada’s passenger trains today? They are deteriorating rapidly and drastic action is required, especially on VIA’s once-great and always-late Canadian. While writing this piece on the afternoon of September 25, I discovered on VIA’s website that one westbound Canadian was seven hours late on the prairies, another was 21 hours late out of Jasper and a Toronto-bound edition was nearly 10 hours late in Northern Ontario. This is typical performance today.
Meanwhile, VIA headquarters staff in their Place Ville Marie offices churn out multi-billion-dollar dream schemes unlikely to ever materialize and feel-good press releases to paper over the whole mess.
Public money is undeniably required to modernize our rail passenger system, but just throwing more bucks into VIA’s mink-lined sink hole isn’t the answer. The government must seriously re-think this hobbled iron horse’s role and craft a rehab plan that outlasts any four-year election cycle. Our elected public servants must be reminded they only have temporary custody of VIA on behalf of its true owners – the public.
The problem here isn’t necessarily Trudeau, it’s his advisers. They don’t understand that a revitalization of our passenger trains would couple with their endlessly-stated devotion to economic stimulus, national unity, regional inclusiveness, tourism development and a national climate change strategy. All would be boosted by improved rail service and all are hampered by letting VIA rot out.
If Trudeau needs affirmation of this, he can just ask any of the six Liberal MPs who possess at least a modicum of appreciation for trains: Andy Fillmore, Geoff Regan, David Graham, Bob Bratina, Ken Hardie and Bob Nault (a former CPR train conductor from Kenora).
Given that so much power rests in the hands of so few on Parliament Hill, Trudeau needs to gather his backroom power brokers for a chat about his very personal rail connections. Advisers such as Gerald Butts and Katie Telford might then grasp what a rail renaissance would do for their leader, their government and their careers, especially with mid-term voter discontent rippling across the land. The PM might pass around the many snapshots showing him enjoying the pleasures of passenger trains in his youth and most recently with his daughter.
To fix our rail passenger system, Trudeau need only act on a view he expressed aboard the CPR’s sesquicentennial train: riding trains reminds us of their role in nation building. He can reset his government’s signals to make our passenger trains nation builders and unifiers again. For reasons both personal and practical, he should do it.
Greg Gormick is a rail analyst and policy adviser whose clients have included VIA, CP, CN and numerous elected officials of all political stripes. He currently serves as transportation adviser to Oxford County in Southwestern Ontario.
- Ontario Protecting Vulnerable Ontarians During COVID-19 Outbreak - April 5, 2020
- Eighth confirmed case of COVID-19 reported by Algoma Public Health - April 4, 2020
- Minister of Education Statement on Tentative Agreement with OCEW - April 4, 2020